In 2026, Indian motorists have two main choices when buying car insurance -
Third-Party
Liability (mandatory by law) or Comprehensive Cover (full
protection).
A third-party policy satisfies the legal requirement but protects only others - not your own
car.
A comprehensive plan includes third-party liability plus own-damage, theft,
fire, and natural-disaster coverage.
The gap between the two is massive: a minor accident can cost more than five years of
third-party premiums combined.
This guide compares both types head-to-head using 2026 premium data, examples, and claim
insights so you can pick the right balance of protection and cost for your car in Hyderabad,
Telangana.
Understanding the Basics
Third-Party Liability Insurance
- Mandatory under the Motor Vehicles Act.
- Covers bodily injury, death, or property damage to others.
- Does not cover your car, passengers, or theft.
Comprehensive Car Insurance
- Includes third-party cover + own-damage (OD) protection.
- Covers accident repair, theft, fire, flood, vandalism, natural disasters.
- Can be enhanced with add-ons like zero-dep, roadside assist, engine protect, NCB
protector.
Coverage Comparison 2026
| Feature |
Third-Party |
Comprehensive |
| Legal requirement |
Mandatory |
Includes TP |
| Own-damage (your car) |
No |
Yes |
| Theft & fire |
No |
Yes |
| Natural calamities |
No |
Yes |
| Personal accident (Owner-Driver) |
Optional add-on |
Usually included |
| Add-ons (Zero Dep, NCB Protect etc.) |
No |
Yes |
| Average annual premium (hatchback, Hyderabad) |
₹1,200-₹1,500 |
₹4,500-₹7,500 |
| Ideal for |
Minimal use / old car |
Daily drivers / new vehicles |
Calculate Your Car
Insurance Premium →
Cost Difference Example 2026
| Vehicle |
Third-Party Premium |
Comprehensive Premium |
Own-Damage Add-ons |
Typical Claim Amount Covered |
| Hatchback (₹5 L IDV) |
₹1,300 |
₹5,000 |
₹800 - ₹1,200 |
₹2 - 3 L accident repair |
| Sedan (₹10 L IDV) |
₹1,700 |
₹7,200 |
₹1,500 - ₹2,000 |
₹4 - 6 L accident repair |
| SUV (₹15 L IDV) |
₹2,100 |
₹9,000 |
₹2,000 - ₹2,500 |
₹6 - 8 L accident repair |
When Third-Party Makes Sense
- Vehicle older than 10 years with low market value.
- Secondary car / weekend vehicle.
- You plan to sell or scrap soon.
- You park in secure private premises and accept repair risk.
When Comprehensive Is a Must in 2026
- Brand-new or financed car (loan mandatory).
- Daily usage / city traffic exposure.
- Flood-prone or accident-heavy region.
- You want full peace of mind against repairs, theft, and disasters.
Add-Ons That Enhance Comprehensive Cover
- Zero Depreciation Cover - 100% parts cost paid.
- NCB Protector - keeps your No Claim Bonus even after a claim.
- Engine & Gearbox Protect - covers hydrostatic damage.
- Roadside Assistance - 24×7 towing and emergency help.
- Consumables Cover - nuts, bolts, engine oil included.
- Return to Invoice - replaces car at invoice value if total loss.
Compare Comprehensive vs
Third-Party Plans →
Claim Process Difference
| Step |
Third-Party |
Comprehensive |
| Who receives payout |
The victim / third party |
You (the policyholder) |
| Repair coverage |
Not applicable |
Cashless / reimbursement |
| Claim timeline |
Legal tribunal based (3 - 12 months) |
7 - 15 working days |
| Documentation |
FIR + RC + TP claim form |
Repair invoice + survey + policy docs |
Legal Note (India 2026)
- Third-party liability insurance is mandatory for all registered
vehicles.
- Driving without valid TP cover can lead to penalties of ₹2,000 and/or 3 - month license
suspension.
- Comprehensive includes TP by default, so you are always legally compliant.
Local Insights Hyderabad
- Avg. claim amount per accident: ₹21,000.
- Most common add-on purchased: Zero Dep + NCB Protector.
- Avg. difference in premium (Comprehensive vs TP): 38% (≈ ₹2,900).
- Top insurers by claim speed: SwiftCover, ABC Insurance, SecureDrive.
FAQs
Is third-party insurance enough?
Only for legal compliance - it does not protect your own vehicle.
Does comprehensive include third-party coverage?
Yes, it includes and extends it.
How much more does comprehensive cost?
Typically 3-5× higher premium but covers 10-20× more risk.
Can I switch from third-party to comprehensive mid-year?
Yes, via upgrade and vehicle inspection.
Does comprehensive cover natural disasters?
Yes - flood, cyclone, landslide, and fire included.
Is Zero Dep mandatory?
No, but highly recommended for cars under 5 years old.
Can I renew comprehensive as only TP later?
Yes, if car value drops below market threshold.
Do both types qualify for tax deduction?
No - personal car policies don’t qualify; commercial vehicles may.
How are claims settled for TP cases?
By Motor Accident Claims Tribunal (MACT) as per IRDAI limits.
Which is better for new cars in 2026
Always Comprehensive + Zero Dep for new vehicles (< 5 yrs).
Buy Comprehensive Car
Insurance Online →
Customer Reviews
- “Comprehensive policy saved me ₹1.8 L after an accident.” - Ravi
Menon
- “Was driving with only third-party - big mistake! Upgraded instantly.” -
Sneha Iyer
- “Zero Dep add-on is a must; PolicyBachat helped me compare easily.” -
Vikram Desai
- “Quick claims and cashless repair - comprehensive was worth it.” -
Kavya Sharma
- “Third-party alone is like wearing half a helmet.” - Rajesh Rao
- “Detailed comparison helped me save ₹2,000 and avoid bad coverage.” -
Meera Nair
PolicyBachat Advantage
- Compare 20+ insurers in one click.
- Real-time premium and IDV calculation.
- See cashless garage networks by city.
- Add Zero Dep and NCB Protector instantly.
- 100% digital purchase + Claim Assist support.
PolicyBachat Tip
Third-party insurance keeps you legal. Comprehensive keeps you safe.
Featured